Fountain Pen Day 2016

Has it really been a year?

Well, let’s see, how did it go?

I did not blog and post as much as I wanted, but I learned to love Instagram and the great community of pen enthusiasts over there.

I have met friends that share my pastime at my second visit of the Hamburg pen show, Pen*Port. And I realized again that it’s all about the people, and I have been incredibly lucky to meet some of the best this community has to offer. Some of them have moved across the globe since then, but I know that this connection we build will make my life more rich no matter how close or distant we live.

I tried some other forms of posts than just reviews, somewhat more of narratives and conversations or thoughts on topics that are points of discussion within our little community of pen nerds.

And I am still enjoying my pens. I’m getting more but at a slower pace. My tastes evolve and change.

So here’s to all of you, of us, and to another year of loving pens and the friends me make over them.

Tim

Tactile Turn Gist

Tactile Turn is a one man shop run by Will Hodges. Will did very well received bodies for ballpoint and gel refills in the past and recently crowd-funded the Gist, his first fountain pen, after .

After some technical difficulties and the resulting delays (this is a Kickstarter project, after all) the Gist is in the hands of backers and I have been using mine for some weeks now.

Design

The Gists big appeal is the mix and match approach to the materials that you can get it in. Body, finial and grip can be machined either from a black polycarbonate or one of several metals.

The pen is 13cm long when capped and only 11,5cm when uncapped. Unposted it is very short and not comfortable for me to write with. Fortunately this pen begs to be posted, which gives you a very comfortable length of 15,5cm. The cap posts deeply and securely, and the polycarbonate material with the ribbing is very durable so it probably won’t leave any marks. I usually don’t like posting my pens but I have no trouble doing it here.

The polycarbonate body with the stainless steel grip section add up to 25 grams including the cap. This is a very light pen, although the metal body variants will no doubt be considerably more heavy.

The overall shape in combination with the black polycarbonate body and the metal grip section is very reminiscent of the Lamy 2000, a timeless design that has stood up to 50 years of progress and new design languages.

The cap screws on, which is a blessing and a curse when it comes to pocket pens. On the one had it stays capped securely and you won’t ever reach for it just to notice that the bare nib is leaking ink into your pocket. On the other hand you can’t just pull off the cap to jot down a quick note, either. I guess I never understood the appeal of pocket pens. There are pens that I am comfortable carrying in a jeans pocket, but they aren’t necessarily pocket pens.

The grip section is long and comfortable and you can grip the pen as low or as high you want to and be comfortable. The machined groves give the section an nice texture that won’t get slippery even during long writing sessions. The threads for the cap are wide and flattened out at the top. They feel like a continuation of the ribbed body pattern and you don’t notice them at all when writing.

Every Gist in existence has been made by one person. Will Hodges is the entirety of Tactile Turn, and I can’t even imagine how stressful it must have been to fulfill so many pledges for such a successful project. And the pen feels well made. The threads are precise, there is no wiggle. Sometimes it seems like the cap sits a little crooked on the pen although the threads are machined well. Maybe it’s an optical illusion.

The Gist uses a cartridge/converter filling system. It comes with a supplied converter and the system works well. The converter looks a little lost and as if it has too much wiggle room in the section, but once you screw the barrel back on everything is tight and secure. I have had no reason to test the Gist with another convert since this one does it’s job well, but be advised that I have heard that most standard international converters are too long for the barrel. The one that come with the pen looks kinda short, so take good care of it, it might not be easy to replace.

Perfomance

A fountain pen is only as good as its nib. You can have the best barrel design, the pretties celluloid or acrylic, golden trim or Sylvester Stallone for promotion and testimonials

If your nibs don’t work, your pen doesn’t work.

The Gist uses Bock nib units.

I hate Bock nib units.

Bock doesn’t stamp their nibs with the nib grade, they never start well for me and the titanium nibs that they offer are so finicky and inconsistent…

I got my Gist with a titanium nib unit. I made that choice before I had received my first titanium nib in the Namisu Nova. This one isn’t any better than my previous experience.

I don’t know what grade I got. Again, the nibs aren’t stamped, and with a titanium nib I just can’t tell! I’m pretty sure I ordered a fine. One day the nib is so wet that it writes closer to a broad, the other one its dry and won’t start when I begin a new word. The tines get knocked out of alignment by just looking at them disapprovingly. Which I do pretty much constantly!

At some point I just gave up and screwed in a steel nib that I got with my Namisu Nexus. They don’t perform well, but at least they are consistently annoying.

Conclusion


I really want to like the Gist. And some days I do. I guess it’s just not for me? I like the look, because I like the look of the Lamy 2000, but I like the Lamy better. I like that it’s pocketable, but I don’t really need a pen that I can carry like that. I like that it is hand made, but then again, there are other pens that are hand made that are just more exiting to me.

And the nibs…

I can tolerate the steel Bock nibs that I got some time ago, but they are not great. The titanium is nice in theory and to play with, but it is a hassle. A pocket pen I expect to perform immediately when I get it out. The steel nibs barely ever do that, and forget about the titanium.

So should you get one? If you have experience with the Bock nibs and like them there is nothing that speaks against it. For me though? This won’t see much use…

What others thinks about the Gist

SBRE Brown has a video on every pen in existence, and that is why we love him so much.

Ed Jelley did a great job capturing the unique design aspects of the Gist in his pictures.

Azizah over at GourmetPens loves the pens and gives them a glowing review that you should read right now.

Matt did a review on PenHabit recently. His videos are a delight, check them out.

peneconomics Lamy followup misses the point

Jonathon Deans has posted some controversial stuff about Lamys future prospects and their current situation and competition. Many people (me included) have been critical of his points and the way he apparently comes to his conclusions. His latest followup seems to address some cherry picked feedback, but in my opinion avoids or misses the most important points. Here are my thoughts on what he has written.

Twsbi may have a real advantage when it comes to the US market, where both the Eco and Safari are roughly the same price, but Lamy hugely outperform in Europe where the price difference is more like 2:1 (even 3:1 in the UK). This is absolutely true and I’m afraid it reflects a bit of sloppiness on my part, and not specifying the market that I was discussing.

Deans makes pretty broad statements, like Lamys premium offerings not being successful and in earlier posts he claimed that the Eco would outsell the Safari (at least for some time). That makes it sound as if he is speaking about Lamys whole business. If he is looking at isolated segments of the market (enthusiasts, geographically…) he should clarify that. But that makes some of his statements (Lamy premium pens failing) even less sound.

[…]Twsbi […] haven’t really invested in European distribution yet. Once they do, their costs should fall, and we should see them become more competitive.

IF they do. IF they CAN. Again, he makes it sound like a certainty that we just need to wait for. If he has any info on that, tell us. If he doesnt, this is wishful thinking.

Ed raises a point on Twitter that comes up now and then, when he points out there’s no data or sources in the Lamy post. As regular readers have probably noticed, that’s standard for this blog even though I understand it can be frustrating for those who want to delve deeper.

Yeah, it’s frustrating alright. Not only for people that want to delve deeper, but mostly because it shows that many of Deans assumptions are baseless (which doesn’t mean they are wrong, we just can’t know), and arguments he builds on them become more and more strange. If he is aware of that I don’t see that in his posts, they read as if he presents assumptions as facts.

Nowadays, academic economics is largely about data, statistics, diagrams, etc and it becomes impenetrable to anyone without a master’s degree. While there are good reasons for this, it also means that economics is often inaccessible to the general public. As this blog is all about making economics more accessible, I decided that I wouldn’t use any equations, any statistics, any diagrams, nothing that would prevent someone with time and interest from understanding any posts.

Thats condescending. Never underestimate your audience. And not showing data, not talking about data, makes it look like you don’t have data. Deans has admitted to me that he doesn’t, and later in this post he dances around the fact but comes close to saying it, too.

The problem is that, even if one retailer or one brand decided to give you access to all of their numbers, it still wouldn’t necessarily be enough to make the kinds of certain judgements that Ed seems to be seeking.

Deans either doesn’t get it or he’s dishonest. It’s not about judgments his critics are seeking, it’s about the judgments HE is making without having data.

Lamy could open the kimono but without Twsbi’s data, it’s really hard to say much at all. […]

Deans should take this paragraph to heart.

My approach then is what’s known in economics as methodological individualism: you think about individual behaviour, either buyers or firms, and try to figure out what’s driving them or why they might do certain things. Thanks to the blogs and forums there’s often plenty of insights available with which to form hypotheses about general phenomena.

The plural of anecdote is not data.

[…]it’s for me to describe what I believe is happening, […]

If Deans is being honest here, if this is not just appeasement, he needd to work on his writing. I read his beliefs regularly stated as facts.

[…]where Lamy fans have had their feelings hurt and have grown critical. And that’s fair enough. There’s an idea called status politics, which claims that some people will closely identify with something — be it a brand, an idea, a lifestyle, a sports team, anything — and want to see it raised in social status. They react strongly against anything which they perceive to lower its status. So you might believe that the homeless lack status and therefore you’ll support any policy which raises their status, regardless of the actual costs and benefits.

Condescending and defensive. Branding critics as fans comes close to an ad hominem fallacy, since Deans are not talking about their points, but about a mechanism that could make them reflexively defensive.